Rejecting a claim by attacking the character, motives, or circumstances of the person making it, rather than addressing the claim itself.
1 · Premise — what you're asked to accept
Person A makes argument X.
2 · Flawed leap — where it breaks
Person A has some flaw or bad motive.
3 · Conclusion — what it tries to sell you
Therefore argument X is false.
“Why should we take his tax proposal seriously? The man has been divorced three times.”
Why it fails · A person's character, history, or motives don't change whether their evidence and reasoning are sound. Evaluate the argument, not the arguer.
Often confused with · Tu Quoque